Tag: civil rights fraud

What Does IBM’s $17 Million FCA Settlement Portend for Government Contractors Wrestling with Compliance?

Jennifer A. Short, Dominique L. Casimir, Brooke T. Iley ●

Jennifer A. Short headshot image

On Friday, April 10, 2026, the Department of Justice (“DOJ”) announced a $17 million False Claims Act (“FCA”) settlement with International Business Machines (“IBM”), based on the company’s alleged violations of federal anti-discrimination laws. The settlement is the first under the DOJ’s Civil Rights Fraud Initiative, created last May with the objective of investigating and prosecuting “illegal DEI” practices, primarily through an FCA lens. Coupled with a new Executive Order—issued on March 26—that imposes contract prohibitions on “racially discriminatory DEI activities” in federal government contracts and subcontracts, the IBM settlement signals an escalation in the government’s focus on DEI programs and employment policies.

The DOJ Press Release and Settlement Agreement

The Alleged “Covered Conduct” Identifies Specific Problematic Practices. 

DOJ alleged that IBM improperly made employment decisions based on protected characteristics through specific programs and actions, described as the “Covered Conduct” for purposes of the settlement agreement:

  • Compensation Incentives: A “diversity modifier” linking bonus compensation to demographic targets
  • Hiring and Promotion Criteria: Basing interview eligibility or prioritization on race, sex, or national origin
  • Demographic Goals for Business Units: Developing race and gender targets tied to employment decisions
  • Limited-Access Programs: Limiting training, mentoring, and leadership development to employees meeting specific demographic criteria, such as minorities.

To read the full alert, please visit our website.

Department of Justice Announces New Initiative to Combat Civil Rights Fraud Using the False Claims Act

Dominique L. Casimir, Jennifer A. Short, and Brooke T. Iley ●

Jennifer A. Short headshot image

From time to time, the Department of Justice (“DOJ”) has established initiatives, task forces, or strike teams to advance its enforcement priorities. In recent years, DOJ has announced a Procurement Collusion Strike Force, a COVID-19 Fraud Enforcement Task Force, and a Civil Cyber-Fraud Initiative, in each instance explicitly invoking a plan to use the False Claims Act (“FCA”) for civil enforcement. 

DOJ announced the latest version of this enforcement approach on May 19, 2025, when Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche issued a memorandum announcing a new Civil Rights Fraud Initiative (“the Initiative”), described as a coordinated and “vigorous” effort to leverage the specter of FCA liability against recipients of federal funding alleged to be violating civil rights laws. The types of alleged civil rights violations targeted by this Initiative relate to diversity, equity, and inclusion (“DEI”) programs, antisemitism, and transgender policy, all of which dovetail with a number of Executive Orders (“EOs”) expressing President Trump’s approach to these issues.

Relevant Executive Orders

Some of the EOs relevant to the Civil Rights Fraud Initiative include:

EO No. 14151: Ending Radical and Wasteful Government DEI Programs and Preferencing (January 20, 2025). This EO directs federal government agencies to end DEI and diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility (“DEIA”) programs, to eliminate positions such as “Chief Diversity Officer,” and to terminate grants and contracts related to DEI and DEIA. It also orders a review of federal employment practices to ensure they focus on individual merit rather than DEI factors.

EO No. 14168: Defending Women From Gender Ideology Extremism and Restoring Biological Truth to the Federal Government (January 20, 2025). This EO declares, as United States’ policy, that there are two immutable sexes (male and female), based on biological reality. It requires changes to government-issued identification documents and prohibits federal funding for so-called “gender ideology.”

EO No. 14173: Ending Illegal Discrimination and Restoring Merit-Based Opportunity (January 21, 2025). This EO requires that all federal contracts and grants include a certification that recipients do not operate any DEI programs that violate applicable antidiscrimination laws and affirms that compliance with federal anti-discrimination laws is material to government payment decisions. Additionally, the EO directs DOJ to identify key sectors and entities for DEI-related enforcement, and to recommend strategies to end “illegal DEI discrimination” in the private sector.

EO No. 14188: Additional Measures To Combat Anti-Semitism (January 29, 2025). This EO reaffirms EO 13899 from December 11, 2019, which aimed to combat antisemitism, particularly in educational institutions. It directs various federal agencies to identify actions to curb antisemitism and recommends monitoring foreign students and staff for antisemitic actions.

EO No. 14201: Keeping Men Out of Women’s Sports (February 5, 2025). This EO aims to exclude transgender individuals from competing in women’s sports. It directs the Secretary of Education to rescind funding from educational institutions that do not comply.

Read the full client alert on our website.